Medicare Plan Checkup · Beta
Your Medicare plan mailed you a letter about next year. Here is what it means in dollars.
Every fall, Medicare Advantage and Part D plans send an Annual Notice of Change. It lists this year’s and next year’s costs side by side, and it is easy to set aside. Upload it, or type the figures in, confirm what it says, and see what changes on January 1, whether changes of that size are worth comparing plans over, and what to do by December 7.
See the sample checkup Check your own letter
Free during the beta, with the same account as Money Assistant. The checkup never tells you which plan to choose. Money Instructor is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program.
Medigap (supplement) policies do not send this letter. If you have Original Medicare with a Medigap policy and a separate Part D plan, use your Part D plan’s letter. No letter by early October? Call member services on your plan card or check the plan’s website.
What you see when it is done
- What changes: premium, deductibles, out-of-pocket maximum, copays and drug tiers, this year next to next year, with the difference.
- Worth comparing? One plain answer, with the reasons listed.
- Medicare’s dates: October 15 to December 7, January 1, and the January-to-March window for Medicare Advantage.
- A checklist with dates, and reminders before the window closes.
- Where to get free help: Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE and your state’s counselors.
The problem it solves
The Annual Notice of Change is the one letter about your plan that matters every year, and it reads like a contract. The premium is on one page, the drug tiers on another, the network changes in a paragraph near the end. Many people keep their plan without comparing; working out what changed can take an afternoon. The checkup does the reading with you: it pulls out the figures, shows you where each one came from, and you confirm each one before anything is added up.
The sample checkup shows it. A fictional plan raises its premium from $0 to $19 a month ($228 more over a year), adds a $200 drug deductible, raises the out-of-pocket maximum by $1,000, raises three copays for care (specialist, emergency room and hospital stay) and one drug copay, and cuts the dental allowance by $250, while mentioning changes to the doctor network. The checkup lists each change, says changes of this size are worth comparing, and gives the dates and the checklist. Open it without an account; the plan and the company are invented.
How it works
Say which plan year
The letter that arrives in the fall is about next year. Pick the kind of plan: Medicare Advantage, with or without drug coverage, or a Part D drug plan. Not sure is fine; the letter usually says.
Upload the letter, or type it in
One PDF, or one clear photo of the page with the “Summary of Important Costs” table, up to 30 pages. No file? Copy the figures from the paper copy. The whole file is sent to an outside document-reading service to be read (and again only if a reading is retried). We ask it only for plan figures; your checkup has no place for your Medicare number, name or address, and a Medicare number found in a quote from the letter is removed. The file is deleted 180 days after you confirm the checkup (or 180 days after upload if you never confirm), and you can delete it sooner.
Check what was read
Every value is shown with its page and the quote it came from. “Looks right” confirms it; a typed correction replaces it; “Not on the letter” leaves it out. Three values are required; the rest are up to you.
See what changed, and what to do
The change table, the plain answer, Medicare’s dates, a checklist you can check off, reminders before December 7, a one-page summary to print, and the free help.
What counts as worth comparing
The answer comes from a short list of thresholds, printed in the app and the same for everyone. Only increases count; a change in your favor is listed separately and never counts against the plan.
| The letter shows | Worth comparing when |
|---|---|
| Monthly premium going up | $120 or more over a year ($10 a month) |
| Maximum out-of-pocket going up | $500 or more |
| A deductible going up | $100 or more |
| A copay going up | $10 or more per visit, or $5 or more per prescription fill |
| A drug tier’s percentage going up | 5 points or more |
| A yearly allowance (dental, over-the-counter) going down | $200 or more |
| Changes to the network, or to extra benefits | Always worth checking |
| The plan is ending | The checkup says so first, with the dates to join new coverage. |
“Worth comparing” means comparing is likely worth an hour of your time. It is never a recommendation to change plans or to keep the one you have; that decision is yours, and the free help below will talk it through with you.
Medicare’s dates
These are Medicare’s published dates for everyone. The checkup never reads a deadline from your letter and never moves a date for a weekend or a holiday.
Free help comparing plans
Medicare.gov Plan Compare
Every plan in your area with next year’s costs, with your own prescriptions and pharmacy entered. Free, and no account is needed to look. Next year’s plans appear on Plan Compare starting October 1.
1-800-MEDICARE and your State Health Insurance Assistance Program
Medicare’s own line is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, except some federal holidays (1-800-633-4227, TTY 1-877-486-2048). Your state’s SHIP has trained counselors who give free, unbiased help by phone or in person.
Help from a licensed agency
The checkup also lists Chapter, a licensed health insurance agency that compares Medicare plans by phone at no charge.
Disclosure: Money Instructor may be paid a referral fee by Chapter if you use its service. This does not change what you pay or what this checkup shows. Chapter is a licensed health insurance agency, paid by insurance companies when you enroll through it, and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program.
Questions people ask
Does it tell me which plan to pick?
No. It shows what your letter says will change, says whether changes of that size are usually worth comparing, and points you to the free comparison tools and counselors. Which plan to choose is your decision.
What happens to my letter?
It is stored privately for your account and read the same way Money Assistant reads a bill. The whole file is sent to an outside document-reading service to be read (and again only if a reading is retried). We ask it only for plan figures; your checkup has no place for your Medicare number, name or address, and a Medicare number found in a quote from the letter is removed. The file is deleted 180 days after you confirm the checkup (or 180 days after upload if you never confirm), and you can delete it sooner. The confirmed figures stay until you delete the checkup or your account.
My letter is 30 pages. Do I need all of it?
No. The first pages, with the “Summary of Important Costs” table, hold most of what matters, plus the drug tier page if your plan covers prescriptions. Upload one PDF of those pages, or one clear photo of the page with the cost table.
Can I do this for my mother’s plan?
Yes, with her permission. Each checkup has its own name, like “Mom’s plan”, and you can keep more than one. The app does not ask for her Medicare number and never contacts her plan or Medicare.
What does it cost?
It is free during the beta. A letter counts as one of the documents your account can read each month; typing the figures in costs nothing.
Does it work for a Medigap (supplement) policy?
No. Medigap (supplement) policies do not send an Annual Notice of Change, so there is nothing for the checkup to read. If you have Original Medicare with a Medigap policy and a separate Part D plan, use your Part D plan’s letter.
See the sample checkup Check your own letter
Educational information, not insurance, financial, legal or tax advice. Money Instructor is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program.