Two Medicare Advantage plans can both advertise a $0 monthly premium and still work very differently for you. Here is a step-by-step way to compare Medicare Advantage plans, starting with your prescriptions, your doctors, and what the plan will really cost over a year.
How to Compare Medicare Advantage Plans Step by Step
How to Compare Medicare Advantage Plans: A Step-by-Step Checklist Before You Enroll
Picture two Medicare Advantage plans side by side. Both advertise a $0 monthly premium, and at first glance they look pretty similar.
But one includes your specialist, and the other leaves that doctor outside its network. Your prescriptions cost less at your usual pharmacy with one plan and more with the other. You would not know any of that from the premium.

So before you enroll, how do you figure out which plan actually works for you? The answer is to start with the care you already use. Check prescriptions, doctors, costs, and the rules for getting care first. Dental and the other extras can wait.
Step 1: Make a One-Page List of the Care You Use
Get one sheet of paper and write down your prescriptions, their doses, and how often you take them. Use the exact name and form of each medicine, because different versions of the same drug may have different coverage.
Then add your doctors, specialists, hospital, and pharmacy. Include any regular therapy, medical equipment you use, and time you spend away from home.
That list is the test each plan has to pass. It is easy to spend twenty minutes comparing dental benefits, then realize the plan does not include your cardiologist.
If You Already Have a Plan, Read Your Annual Notice of Change
Put your plan’s Annual Notice of Change beside your list. It arrives in the fall and explains what is changing in January.
You may recognize the plan name on the envelope, but that does not mean the costs and benefits stayed the same. Read what is changing, then verify next year’s drug coverage and provider network. (Our guide on what to check before you keep your plan walks through the notice in more detail.)
Step 2: Know How Medicare Advantage Works, Then Open Plan Finder
Before you start searching, make sure you are comfortable with the basics. With Medicare Advantage, you get your Part A and Part B benefits through a Medicare-approved private plan, which usually includes Part D drug coverage too. You generally keep paying your Part B premium.
Original Medicare generally lets you see any doctor or hospital nationwide that takes Medicare. Advantage plans often use networks, but they have a yearly spending limit for covered medical care. Original Medicare has no such limit unless you have other coverage. That tradeoff matters.
With that in mind, open Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov. Enter your location, medicines, doses, and pharmacies. Check the coverage year, especially if you are shopping in the fall for coverage that starts in January.
The estimated yearly drug and premium costs can help you narrow things down. Once you have a few possibilities, take a closer look at each one.
Step 3: Check Your Medicines
Find each of your medicines on the plan’s formulary, which is its list of covered drugs. Check the tier, because the tier helps determine what you pay.
Don’t stop there. Look for coverage rules attached to each drug:
- Prior authorization. The medicine is on the list, but the plan may need to approve coverage before it pays for your refill.
- Step therapy. You may need to try a specified medicine first.
- Quantity limits. The plan may limit how much of a drug it covers.
Check the pharmacy while you are there. A preferred pharmacy may cost less than another pharmacy in the same network.
What you are really trying to answer is this: What will my prescriptions cost where I fill them, and what rules stand between me and a refill?
Two Part D Numbers to Know for 2027
The maximum Part D deductible for 2027 is $700, though plans may charge less or none.
The yearly out-of-pocket threshold for covered Part D drugs is $2,400. Once you reach it, you pay nothing out of pocket for covered Part D drugs for the rest of that calendar year. Premiums and noncovered medicines are separate, and this protection applies to covered Part D drugs only. The limit on medical spending is a different number, covered in Step 5.

Step 4: Check Your Doctors, Hospital, and Network Rules
With your drug costs in front of you, turn to your doctors. Look in the plan’s directory, call the plan, and confirm with each provider’s office. Give them the exact plan name and coverage year.
If someone says, “We take Medicare,” keep going. That does not tell you whether your doctor participates in this particular Advantage plan. “We work with that insurance company” is not specific enough either. Write down who confirmed it and when.
Do the same for your hospital and other facilities. Your doctor being in the network does not automatically mean every place they refer you is included. (Some hospitals are leaving Medicare Advantage networks for 2027, so check yours.)
If you spend winters with family in another state, ask where you could get a routine follow-up visit there. Emergency coverage is important, but it does not settle how an ordinary appointment works away from home.
HMO vs. PPO: What the Letters Mean in Practice
An HMO generally requires you to use network care, apart from emergency care, out-of-area urgent care, and temporary out-of-area dialysis. It usually requires referrals to see specialists too.
A PPO generally allows covered care outside the network at a higher cost, without specialist referrals. Even so, confirm the coverage and confirm that the provider will see you. Think about the appointments you would actually make.
Step 5: Add Up What Using the Plan Will Cost
Once you know where you can get care, look at what using the plan will cost. Include premiums, deductibles, specialist visits, hospital stays, and any other care you expect.
A $0 plan premium does not mean free care. You still owe the Part B premium, although some plans help pay part or all of it.
Notice whether you pay a fixed copayment or coinsurance, which is a percentage of the covered cost. A percentage can be harder to budget for.
Example: Two Plans, Same Yearly Bill
Here is how that works with some made-up numbers. Plan A has no monthly plan premium and charges $50 per specialist visit. Plan B charges $30 a month and $20 per visit.
- Plan A, 12 visits: 12 × $50 = $600
- Plan B, 12 visits: $360 in premiums + $240 for visits = $600
The premiums looked different, but this part of the yearly bill came out equal. Drugs, hospital care, and other charges still need comparing.

Plan for a Difficult Health Year
What happens if you have a hard health year? Find the plan’s medical out-of-pocket maximum. It limits your costs for covered Part A and Part B services under the plan’s rules.
Premiums, Part D drugs, and noncovered services are separate. A PPO can have one limit for network care and another for combined network and outside care.
Could your budget handle that amount during a serious illness? You cannot predict the year, but you can check the protection.

🆓 Comparing Medicare plans? Get free expert help.
Choosing between Medicare options is one of the most important financial decisions you’ll make — and the stakes are real. Our partner Chapter Medicare offers free, unbiased guidance from licensed advisors who specialize in Medicare plan selection.
📞 Call 615-639-1937 | 🔗 askchapter.org/money
Help is ALWAYS FREE. Chapter is compensated by insurance carriers, not by you.
Step 6: Check the Rules, the Extras, and the Plan Documents
There is still the process of getting care. A referral is your doctor’s direction to see a specialist. Prior authorization is approval from the plan for certain services or supplies. Those are different steps.
If you are receiving ongoing treatment, ask what needs approval, who requests it, and how continued care is handled.
Now Look at Dental, Vision, Hearing, and Star Ratings
Now you can come back to the extras. Dental sounds useful, but suppose you need a crown and the benefit mainly covers cleanings. Look at covered services, dollar limits, participating providers, and your share of the bill. Check vision, hearing, and other benefits the same way.
Useful extras cannot make up for a plan that does not meet your main care needs. Use star ratings as information about quality, but they cannot tell you whether your doctors and medicines fit.
Read the Summary of Benefits and Evidence of Coverage
Before enrolling, read the Summary of Benefits and the Evidence of Coverage for that exact plan and year.
If you have employer, union, veterans, or other coverage, check with that benefits office before changing it. And before dropping a Medigap policy, find out whether you could buy it again later. Timing, health questions, protections, and state rules can all affect that option.
Step 7: Know the Enrollment Dates and Get Free Help
Medicare Open Enrollment runs October 15 through December 7, and changes generally start January 1.
If you are already in a Medicare Advantage plan, you generally get one change from January 1 through March 31. You can move to another Advantage plan or to Original Medicare, with an opportunity to join a drug plan. Qualifying events may also give you a special enrollment opportunity.
If you get stuck, SHIP, your State Health Insurance Assistance Program, offers free, unbiased Medicare counseling. If costs are a problem, ask about Medicare Savings Programs or Extra Help, because you may qualify for assistance. Our Benefits Finder and our guide to Medicare Savings Programs and the Part B premium can help you start.
You can enroll through Plan Finder, through the plan, or by calling 1-800-MEDICARE. Save your confirmation and the effective date.
A Free Worksheet to Compare Plans Side by Side
The video points to a Medicare Plan Comparison Worksheet at Benefits Instructor. It gives you a column for each plan, so you can line up premiums, deductibles, drugs, doctors, the out-of-pocket limit, and extras as you work through these steps.
From Money Instructor
Compare Medicare plans with Benefits Instructor
Our companion site devoted to benefits has a printable plan comparison worksheet, an Open Enrollment checklist, a guide to your Annual Notice of Change, and plain-English guides to Medicare, Medicare Savings Programs, Extra Help, and more.
Visit Benefits Instructor →Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Choosing by premium alone. A $0 premium says nothing about your specialist, your drugs, or your yearly costs.
- Trusting “We take Medicare.” Confirm your doctor participates in that exact plan for that coverage year.
- Stopping when you find your drug on the list. Check its tier, prior authorization, step therapy, quantity limits, and pharmacy pricing.
- Shopping extras first. Dental and vision matter only after the plan passes the test of your doctors and medicines.
- Dropping Medigap without checking. Find out first whether you could buy it again later.
What This Means for You
Comparing Medicare Advantage plans is not about finding the lowest premium or the longest list of extras. It is about whether a plan fits the care you already use.
Start with your list, then check your medicines, your doctors, your total costs, and the rules for getting care. Those two $0 plans from the start of this article look very different once you do. That is the point of checking before you choose.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I compare first in a Medicare Advantage plan?
Start with the care you already use: your prescriptions, then your doctors, hospital, and pharmacy, then your total costs and the rules for getting care. Leave dental and other extras for last.
Does a $0 premium Medicare Advantage plan mean free care?
No. You still generally pay your Part B premium, and you still owe deductibles, copayments, or coinsurance when you use care. Some plans help pay part or all of the Part B premium.
How do I know if my doctor is in a Medicare Advantage plan’s network?
Check the plan’s directory, call the plan, and confirm with the doctor’s office using the exact plan name and coverage year. “We take Medicare” is not enough. Write down who confirmed it and when.
What is the difference between an HMO and a PPO?
An HMO generally requires network care, except for emergencies and a few other cases, and usually requires specialist referrals. A PPO generally covers care outside the network at a higher cost and does not require specialist referrals.
What are the Part D drug cost limits for 2027?
The maximum Part D deductible is $700, and plans may charge less or none. Once you reach the $2,400 out-of-pocket threshold, you pay nothing for covered Part D drugs for the rest of the calendar year.
Can I switch Medicare Advantage plans after January 1?
If you are already in Medicare Advantage, you generally get one change from January 1 through March 31, to another Advantage plan or to Original Medicare with a drug plan. Qualifying events may also allow special enrollment.
Your Plan Comparison Checklist
- Write down your prescriptions, doctors, hospital, pharmacy, and time away from home.
- Read your Annual Notice of Change if you already have a plan.
- Use Medicare Plan Finder for the right coverage year.
- Check each drug’s tier and rules, and your pharmacy’s price.
- Confirm every doctor and facility with the plan and the office.
- Add up yearly costs and check the medical out-of-pocket maximum.
- Read the Summary of Benefits and Evidence of Coverage, then enroll by December 7.
🆓 Ready to compare plans for your situation?
Every Medicare situation is different. Our partner Chapter Medicare offers free one-on-one help from licensed advisors who can compare options based on your doctors, prescriptions, and budget.
📞 Call 615-639-1937 | 🔗 askchapter.org/money
ALWAYS FREE. No obligation.
Disclosure: We may receive a referral from Chapter if you choose to use their service. Chapter is a licensed health insurance agency and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Medicare or any government agency.
Money Instructor provides educational information only and does not offer medical, insurance, legal, or financial advice. Medicare plans, networks, costs, and enrollment rules change each year and may not apply to your situation. Review the plan’s Summary of Benefits and Evidence of Coverage and confirm details with Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, the plan, your providers, or your state’s SHIP before making coverage decisions.


